In the past few days, our group has talked a lot about the lack of traditional tragic elements in Hamlet.Â Though there is a lot of death in this final scene, there are also elements of comedy in conversations with the gravediggers and Oseric, as well as an unexpected resolution between Laertes and Hamlet.Â Additionally, Hamlet lacks the fundamental fatal mistake that many tragic heroes have. Â (See here for further information about elements of tragedies.) Â However, all of these are qualitative assumptions. Â The major question is, how can the tools at our disposal help us to better understand the classification of Hamlet? Monk was the obvious choice to aid in this question, but as April suggests, Monk is equally confused about the â€œtragedinessâ€ of Hamlet, and none of us are 100% certain why this is.
Iâ€™m not sure exactly how to clarify the question, but I attempted to take a stab at it using my tool.Â I started by choosing words from my previous List Word result that I thought were particularly indicative of a tragedy.Â In this process, I came up with a list of 12 words: know, dead, grave, death, die, life, purpose, nature, cause, soul, blame and fault.Â I then ran these words through the Concordance Tool to see what limited context TAPoR could supply.
I also ran these words with the fifth Act from Macbeth.Â Everybody in the group agreed that this play displayed the most definite signs of a tragedy, so I used it as a control with which to compare my results with.
The goal was to identify how these words are used differently or similarly in Hamlet and MacbethÂ (I apologize that the screenshots cannot show the entirety of my results), Â though I am not sure that they are good representations. Â I immediately concluded that that this job is perhaps best suited for Wordseer or Wordhoard, because then the context and speaker are identified with more ease. Â However, there were a few surprising results.Â For instance, I did not expect the words â€œcauseâ€ and â€œblameâ€ to be common in both of these final acts.Â Moreover, they seem to both be used in reference to the King (though it has been a long time since I read Macbeth so I canâ€™t exactly be sure).Â It made me think of the similarities between Macbeth and Claudius.Â Even though Claudius is not the protagonist of the play, he resembles a tragic hero like Macbeth more than Hamlet does. Â Both are spurred by ambition and die because of it.Â So the question is, do elements of a tragedy need to belong solely to the protagonist?
Overall, my results at this point are not very conclusive.Â I think in the coming days I will dabble a bit in the other tools while consulting with my peers, Â Hopefully this willÂ yieldÂ further evidence regarding the lack or abundance of tragedy in Hamlet.Â I am particularly interested to discover how Hamletâ€™s word usage indicates him as the tragic hero and not just a victim of circumstance.Â Iâ€™m not sure how to best approach this problem yet, but hopefully my peers will have some ideas.